Introduction
Before selecting a current sensor suitable for your application, it's crucial to fully understand the conditions under which the sensor will operate when integrated into the actual system. If the measurement range is too narrow, it may fail to detect overcurrent faults that occur during motor lock-up (stall) or inrush current. On the other hand, if the measurement range is too wide, measurement accuracy and system efficiency may decrease, and the signal you want to measure may be buried in noise.
This article presents a systematic approach to selecting the optimal Allegro current sensor based on sensor technology characteristics and application-specific current profiles. It also explains the differences between products employing proven and reliable Hall-effect technology and those employing cutting-edge, high-performance tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) technology. Furthermore, it emphasizes the importance of understanding and evaluating the overall system current profile, which is essential for appropriate sensor selection.
This article is part of a series of current sensor selection guides that provide engineers with guidance to understand the important trade-offs of various sensor technologies and make appropriate choices. For related content in the series, please refer to "Beyond the Datasheet: Mastering Current Sensing Selection".
Sensing technology
The performance, accuracy, and robustness of a current sensor depend heavily on the underlying sensing technology it employs. Allegro MicroSystems leverages multiple advanced magnetic sensing technologies to meet the diverse application demands of today.
This section explains the operating principles of Allegro's main sensing technologies, Hall-effect technology and TMR (Tunnel Magneto-Resistance) technology, and the benefits they offer.
Hall-effect technology
The Hall effect has long been central to magnetic sensing technology due to its high reliability, excellent cost-effectiveness, and ease of integration into standard semiconductor manufacturing processes. When an electric current flows through a conductive plate (Hall plate) and a magnetic field is applied perpendicular to the plate, the charge carriers are deflected by the Lorentz force.
As a result, a measurable voltage, known as Hall Voltage, is generated at both ends of the plate. This Hall Voltage changes in proportion to the strength of the magnetic field. In Allegro's integrated current sensor, a metal conductor guides the current being measured into the device and then back out. This creates a magnetic field around the semiconductor chip (die) due to the current. The Hall plate detects this magnetic field and converts it into a voltage signal proportional to its strength.
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Design points
For many industrial and automotive applications, we recommend considering Hall effect sensor technology as a starting point for your selection. Allegro's Hall effect sensors are highly robust, thoroughly characterized, and widely used thanks to their proven track record and support system.
In particular, Hall effect technology is a viable option when the application's rated current exceeds 20A, the required bandwidth is less than 400kHz, and there are no stringent requirements for low power consumption. In such applications, Hall effect sensors generally offer more cost-effective solutions that meet performance requirements, along with a wide range of package and gain setting options, allowing for flexible design.
Figure: Hall effect (blue arrow B: magnetic field applied perpendicular to the Hall plate) *Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Comparison of single-hole and dual-hole (differential) systems
When measuring magnetic fields using a single Hole plate, the sensor is susceptible to unwanted external magnetic fields (stray fields). For example, magnetic fields generated from other current traces or surrounding traces on the substrate can cause measurement errors. To address this challenge, Allegro widely employs differential sensing technology, in which two Hole plates are symmetrically positioned on either side of the internal current conductor.
The target magnetic field generated by the conductor current acts as a signal of equal magnitude and opposite polarity on each Hall plate. On the other hand, stray magnetic fields from the outside act equally on both Hall plates as common-mode signals. Therefore, by taking the difference between the signals obtained from the two Hall plates, the influence of the stray magnetic field, which is a common-mode component, can be canceled out, and only the signal component to be measured can be emphasized. As a result, immunity to external magnetic noise is greatly improved, achieving a performance that is extremely important for current sensors used in environments with a lot of electrical noise.
Design points
If your application is used near motors, transformers, or busbars and wiring carrying high currents, we recommend considering the use of differential sensing. In such environments, single-element Hall sensors may not be able to provide sufficient measurement performance due to the susceptibility to stray magnetic fields from the surroundings. In actual printed circuit board (PCB) environments, differential sensing, which can suppress the influence of external magnetic fields, is generally more suitable.
Tunnel MagnetoResistance (TMR) Technology
TMR is a sensing technology that utilizes quantum mechanical phenomena and can achieve higher performance compared to conventional Hall effect technology. Allegro's XtremeSense™ TMR technology is one of the most advanced technologies in the field of magnetic sensing. TMR sensors are composed of a structure called a magnetic tunnel junction (MTJ). An MTJ is a multilayer structure with an extremely thin insulating film sandwiched between two ferromagnetic layers. The electrical resistance of an MTJ depends largely on the relative relationship of the magnetization directions of the two ferromagnetic layers.
When the magnetization directions are aligned, electrons can more easily pass through the insulating film via tunneling, resulting in lower resistance. Conversely, when the magnetization directions are opposite, electrons have difficulty passing through, significantly increasing resistance. In a TMR sensor, the magnetization direction of one magnetic layer is fixed and is called the reference layer. The other magnetic layer is called the free layer, and its magnetization direction rotates in response to changes in the external magnetic field. This change in the magnetization direction of the free layer causes a large and predictable change in the resistance of the MTJ, and this resistance change is ultimately output as a voltage signal.
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
For a given magnetic field, the TMR effect generates a much larger output signal than the Hall effect. The output level typically reaches 100 to 1000 times greater. This high sensitivity significantly improves the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). In current sensing, this results in high resolution, enabling more accurate measurements, especially in the low-current range. Because the TMR can generate a larger output signal for the same magnetic field, it already achieves excellent SNR at the raw signal stage output from the sensing element.
On the other hand, Hall effect sensors require a high amplification factor (gain) to raise the signal to a practical level. However, increasing the gain amplifies not only the signal but also the noise. In contrast, TMR technology, due to its high initial signal level, can reduce the amount of amplification required to obtain the same output level, resulting in superior noise performance. Furthermore, because the TMR effect itself is a physical phenomenon that occurs instantaneously, TMR technology is very suitable for high-bandwidth applications. Fast-responding current sensors enable more accurate and safer control in high-speed switching power electronics equipment using SiC (silicon carbide) and GaN (gallium nitride), which have become increasingly popular in recent years.
Design points
Generally, TMR technology is more suitable if the following conditions are met:
- If the rated current is less than 10A
- When the switching frequency exceeds 400kHz
- In designs where reducing current consumption is important, such as in battery-powered devices.
- In power stages using SiC (silicon carbide) or GaN (gallium nitride), conventional Hall effect sensors cannot accurately track the changes.
When a sharp current transient occurs
Comparison of Hall method and TMR method
Understanding the right sensor technology is important, but it's not enough. Even the highest-performing sensor won't perform to its full potential if it doesn't properly respond to the actual current levels flowing through the system.
Therefore, the next step in selecting the optimal current sensor is to correctly understand the current profile (current characteristics) in the target application. The main differences between the Hall method and the TMR method are shown in the table below.
|
parameter |
Hall effect |
TMR method |
Why it is important |
| Sensing principle | The Lorentz force deflects charge carriers in silicon, generating a voltage proportional to the magnetic field. | The quantum tunneling resistance between ferromagnetic layers changes in response to the external magnetic field. | |
| sensitivity | high | Very high | The higher the sensitivity, the larger the signal that can be used before amplification. |
| Noise floor | High: Thermal noise and 1/f noise | Low: The large signal inherent to the element improves the signal-to-noise ratio without adding gain. | This directly affects the minimum detectable current and measurement accuracy. |
| S/N ratio (SNR) | Good: Suitable for most industrial and automotive current ranges. | Excellent: Clearly superior performance in the low-current range. | Important for high-precision control loops and power measurement. |
| Bandwidth / Response Time | Wideband: Allegro Hall effect devices support up to 400kHz. | Extremely wide bandwidth: Inherently fast due to the quantum tunneling mechanism. Allegro's TMR devices support up to 5MHz. | Determining the performance in tracking high-speed transient changes in switching power stages. |
| Low current performance | Better performance in the 10A to over 20A range. At low currents, the noise floor becomes a limiting factor. | Excellent: Designed to measure extremely low currents with high precision. | This will be a key differentiating factor for battery monitoring and low-power IoT devices. |
| power consumption | low | Extremely low | |
| Resistance to external magnetic fields | Good: Common-mode stray magnetic fields are eliminated by differential sensing. | Good: Common-mode stray magnetic fields are eliminated by differential sensing. | Both technologies require proper PCB layout design. |
| temperature stability | Thoroughly characterized over a wide temperature range. Established data for automotive grade applications. | Excellent: The resistance ratio of TMRs is inherently less susceptible to temperature changes than Hall voltages. | Important in high-temperature automotive and industrial environments. |
| Compatibility with SiC/GaN | Support: High-bandwidth devices capable of tracking high-speed switching transients | Compatibility: Features extremely fast response times, ideal for wide-bandgap power electronics. | Both technologies are compatible with the latest power electronics. TMR offers the highest dI/dt tracking capability. |
| Package options | Abundant: A wide variety of package families are available to accommodate a broad current range. | Expanding: Expanding our product portfolio for a variety of applications. | This affects PCB mounting area, thermal management, and system integration options. |
| Typical uses | Motor drives, industrial power monitoring, automotive applications, consumer electronics | High-precision power consumption measurement, battery management, low-power IoT, high-speed power conversion | |
| Allegro Current Sensor | ACS37002 / ACS37003 ACS37010 / 2 ACS37030 / 2 ACS37035 |
ACS37100 CT4022 / CT4032 |
Current sensing range
Selecting the appropriate current sensing range is a fundamental and crucial first step in choosing a current sensor. The sensing range refers to the current range within which the sensor can accurately measure current and convert that value into a proportional output signal. To ensure both measurement accuracy and system reliability, it is essential to appropriately match the sensor's measurement range to the application's current profile.
Using a sensor with too narrow a measurement range can cause it to saturate, making accurate current measurement impossible. On the other hand, using a sensor with too wide a measurement range can reduce sensitivity and resolution, making it difficult to adequately capture minute current changes.
The balance in range selection is important.
Selecting a current measurement range always involves trade-offs. The key is to choose the optimal range for the overall system operating profile, including not only the rated current but also the peak current. If the sensor's measurement range is smaller than the peak current generated by the system, the sensor output will saturate. When saturated, the sensor output will stick to the maximum or minimum voltage (clipping or railing), and currents exceeding the saturation point cannot be measured, or cannot be measured accurately.
This is particularly dangerous in systems that use sensors for overcurrent protection. Because the actual peak current value cannot be captured, abnormal conditions cannot be detected correctly, which can lead to system damage. For example, consider a motor application where a 40A inrush current flows at startup, and a sensor with a ±20A range is used. In this case, the sensor output will saturate, and it will not be possible to obtain useful information to determine the peak current or the magnitude of the overcurrent condition.
On the other hand, if the sensor's measurement range is too large for the application's steady-state operating current, it can lead to a decrease in resolution and a deterioration of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). The sensor's output sensitivity is directly related to its measurement range and is usually expressed in mV/A. Generally, sensors with larger measurement ranges have lower sensitivity. That is, even with the same current change, the change in output voltage will be smaller. For example, if a sensor with a ±400A range is used for a system with a steady-state current of 10A, the resulting output signal will be very small. This makes it difficult to distinguish a valid signal from the sensor's own noise and the surrounding system noise, potentially making high-precision measurement difficult. Such situations can negatively impact the performance of the control loop and the accuracy of power monitoring.
Design points
In the early stages of design, it is recommended to select a sensor with a measurement range of approximately 1.5 to 2 times the expected maximum transient current (peak transient current). This design guideline not only ensures a sufficient margin to prevent sensor saturation but also maintains the steady-state operating current well above the noise floor. By applying the 1.5 to 2 times rule, even slight changes in current can be detected as an identifiable change in output voltage.
For example, even small current changes, such as the difference between 7.9A and 8.1A, can be distinguished and measured if the sensor has sufficient resolution. On the other hand, if the appropriate range is not selected, these differences may be buried in noise and may not be accurately detected. In addition, it is important to ensure that the output does not clip (saturate) when peak current occurs, as well as to ensure the output resolution necessary to control typical loads with high precision. To achieve this, the sensor output must be sufficiently clean and accurate in steady-state operating currents, and have sufficient sensitivity to track even minute current changes.
Examples of saturation due to insufficient measurement range
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Examples of resolution degradation due to an excessively large measurement range
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Examples of selecting an appropriate measurement range
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Understanding the System Current Profile
To select the optimal current measurement range, it is crucial to first have a thorough understanding of the overall system current profile. Furthermore, designers must carefully evaluate several critical parameters to ensure that the selected sensor meets the application requirements.
System current profile
Nominal Operating Current: This is the typical current value that a system continuously consumes or supplies during normal operation. Current sensors require the highest measurement accuracy and resolution in this range.
Example of a steady-state current profile (highest level of measurement accuracy and resolution is crucial in this region)
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Peak transient current (surge current/inrush current): This refers to the maximum current that can occur in a system, even temporarily. This includes motor starting current and stall current, inrush current during capacitor charging, and current during short-circuit faults. Current sensors must be able to accurately measure these peak currents without saturating. Furthermore, for applications detecting fault currents, it is important to select sensors with high-speed response performance and fault detection output functions. For example, the ACS37010, ACS37032, and ACS37035 have built-in overcurrent fault detection functions and are suitable for such applications.
Example of peak transient current (For fault detection, the sensor needs to be able to measure the peak current without saturating).
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Frequency and Alternating Current (AC): Alternating current (AC) is a current whose direction reverses at regular intervals and generally changes sinusoidally. AC current is widely used in household appliances, power grids, and power conversion systems. In applications measuring AC current, the sensor must be able to accurately measure both the positive and negative peak values of the AC signal. When measuring AC current in devices such as onboard chargers (OBCs) or DC-DC converters, consider using a bidirectional current sensor with sufficient frequency response performance.
Furthermore, the sensor's bandwidth must be wide enough to accurately measure all frequency components contained in the AC signal. Bandwidth indicates the frequency range that the sensor can accurately measure. In addition, the selected measurement range must adequately cover the expected peak values of the AC current. AC current is usually expressed in RMS (Root Mean Square), but the sensor must be able to handle peak currents larger than the RMS value. For example, if the AC current is 20 Arms, the sensor must be able to measure a peak current of at least 20 Arms x √2 = 28.3 APK.
Example of AC current (requires bidirectional sensing and sufficient bandwidth; the measurement range should be selected based on peak current rather than RMS value)
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
Design points
To accurately measure non-sinusoidal waveforms, it is generally recommended to set the sensor bandwidth to at least 5 times, and preferably 10 times or more, the fundamental frequency of the signal. This allows for proper capture of harmonic components, enabling more accurate reproduction and measurement of the waveform.
Maximum Continuous Current: Continuous current refers to the steady-state current that flows continuously in one direction through the sensor. The maximum continuous current is the maximum current that the sensor can continuously measure in a steady-state operating state without exceeding thermal limitations or specified accuracy specifications. This parameter is particularly important in applications where a nearly constant current flows for extended periods. To prevent sensor overheating and permanent damage, proper thermal design is necessary to ensure that the sensor's maximum junction temperature (TJMAX) is not exceeded.
Furthermore, the power loss generated by the sensor must be kept at a level that maintains the junction temperature below 165°C. The maximum continuous current is a package-specific characteristic and actually depends heavily on the application's implementation conditions. Therefore, even within the Allegro product family, the maximum allowable continuous current varies depending on the package.
When using the sensor under conditions close to the package's maximum continuous current, implement appropriate heat dissipation measures and ensure a sufficient thermal design margin. In particular, in enclosed enclosures or poorly ventilated environments, it is crucial to allow ample margin for temperature rise. It is recommended to verify the junction temperature through actual measurement. The temperature on the top surface of the package can be used as an approximate indicator of the die temperature. Furthermore, always ensure that the junction temperature does not exceed the maximum allowable temperature of 165°C.
Current direction:
Unidirectional: This refers to applications where current flows in only one direction. For example, typical power supply load circuits fall into this category.
For a one-way sensor, the output voltage when the current is 0A is VDD/10.
• Bidirectional: This refers to applications where current flows in both the positive and negative directions. Examples include battery charging and discharging, and forward/reverse control of motors.
Many Allegro current sensors, including the ACS37002 and ACS37030, support bidirectional measurement.
In a bidirectional sensor, the output voltage is VDD/2 when the current is 0A.
Comparison of unidirectional current detection and bidirectional current detection.
*Provided by Allegro MicroSystems
When a malfunction occurs or there is a possibility of reverse current flow, the use of a bidirectional sensor is recommended. Bidirectional sensors can measure current in both forward and reverse directions, whereas unidirectional sensors will saturate if current flows in the opposite direction to the measurable direction. As a result, reverse current cannot be accurately measured, which may affect fault diagnosis and protection functions.
|
parameter |
Definition |
Design considerations |
| Typical operating current | Steady-state load current | Determine the resolution and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) requirements. |
| Peak transient current (inrush current / stall current) | Instantaneous maximum current | The sensor must not become saturated. |
| Maximum continuous current | Thermal limits during continuous DC power supply | Influences the selection of package and thermal design. |
| AC frequency component | Current reversal speed | Determine the required bandwidth. |
| Current direction | Unidirectional/Bidirectional | Determine the output method (reference voltage center / rail-to-rail). |
Table: Overview of Current Profiles
Practical example: Selection of a current sensor
Let's consider a battery-powered tool equipped with a brushless DC motor (BLDC) as an example. The current profile of this system is as follows:
• Steady-state operating current: 8A
• Peak current at startup: 60A
In this case, using a ±20A range sensor allows for high-resolution measurement of the 8A steady-state operating current, but the sensor becomes completely saturated during motor startup, making it impossible to monitor the 60A peak current. On the other hand, a ±100A range sensor can adequately measure the peak current during startup. However, its lower sensitivity reduces the measurement accuracy for the 8A steady-state operating current.
In contrast, a sensor with a ±65A range, such as the ACS37032LLZATR-065B3, is an ideal choice. This range provides sufficient margin for accurately measuring peak currents of 60A while also achieving good resolution and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in the steady-state operating range of 8A, enabling highly accurate control. Thus, by thoroughly analyzing the current profile of the entire system and understanding the trade-off between "saturation margin" and "resolution," it is possible to select the optimal Allegro current sensor for high-performance and reliable operation.
Summary
The selection of a current sensor is a critical design decision that directly impacts the performance, reliability, and safety of a system. As explained in this article, a thorough understanding of the system's entire current profile, from steady-state operating currents to maximum transient current events, is essential for selecting the appropriate sensor. Furthermore, by properly evaluating the trade-offs between measurement range, resolution, and saturation, and carefully considering whether to employ proven Hall effect technology or TMR technology for high-precision measurement performance, designers can achieve highly efficient and reliable system designs.
As demonstrated in the BLDC motor example, a systematic approach that comprehensively considers all operating conditions is key to selecting the optimal sensor for application-specific requirements. Such an approach not only achieves optimal measurement performance but also ensures high reliability over the long term. This article is part of a comprehensive series on current sensor selection. For related content in this series, please refer to "Beyond the Datasheet: Mastering Current Sensing Selection."
Inquiry
If you have any questions regarding this article, please contact us below.
Allegro MicroSystems Manufacturer Information Top Page
If you would like to return to the Allegro MicroSystems manufacturer information top page, please click below.